Traditional Views On Stranger Rape Criminology Essay

“ I prefer to qualify colza merely as a signifier of anguish. Like the torturer, the raper is motivated by the impulse to rule, humiliate, and destruct his victim. Like a torturer, he does so by utilizing the most intimate Acts of the Apostless available to worlds — sexual 1s. ”

Hire a custom writer who has experience.
It's time for you to submit amazing papers!

order now

Helen Benedict, Virgin or Vamp, 1992

Rape is the act of forced, unwanted sexual assault. It can be a signifier of sexual torment or sexual intercourse. This can be done by a alien, an familiarity, or a household member. Globally, colza is an happening offense that victimizes non lone adult females but besides kids and work forces excessively ( Starman, 2009 ) .In 1997, harmonizing to the Worldwide Sexual Assault Statistics there is a big per centum of sexual assault victims that are less than 15 old ages old ( 2005 ) . In 2000, there was a study that in seven different states, 60 % of sexual assault victims know their aggressors. In 2001, 1 out of 3 adult females worldwide has experienced colza or sexual assault ( Worldwide Sexual Assault Statistics, 2005 ) . Besides, in an intensive survey, it was found that in eight different states, 24.7 % experient sexual force in dating relationships ( Worldwide Sexual Assault Statistics, 2005 ) . Besides, the Worldwide Sexual Assault Statistics reported that surveies showed that 5-10 per centum of work forces experience sexual assault in their childhood yearss ( 2005 ) . These statistics imply that colza is a really serious offense. Even household members can non be excused out of it. Harmonizing to Susan Estrich, there are two types of colza: “ traditional ” colza – described to be a violent colza committed by a alien and “ non-traditional ” colza – described to be a less violent colza committed by an familiarity of the victim ( qtd. by Shanahan, 1999 ) . Estrich suggested that “ non-traditional ” colza requires a less terrible penalty compared to the “ traditional ” colza ( qtd. by Shanahan, 1999 ) . However, this is an unjust line of thought. Rape is a offense. It is non dependent on who did it and who the victim is. In this paper, the first portion will discourse colza and its history. The 2nd portion will discourse about and compare the two types of colza: “ traditional ” colza and “ non-traditional ” colza. Emphasis will be given to the “ traditional ” alien colza instance. The 3rd portion will discourse the current punishments that are given to the rapers. Emphasis will besides be given to the “ traditional ” alien colza instance. A thorough rating of the punishments and its deductions will be discussed. The last portion will discourse about how this “ traditional ” alien position fails to reasonably and accurately stand for the true nature of colza as an offense.

Rape foremost appeared on historical texts in the signifier of early spiritual texts. Rape is normally denoted both as abduction and in a sexual sense. In Grecian Mythology, some celebrated narratives depicted colza of adult females and male colza. First is the “ colza ” of Europa by Zues, It was written that Europa, a Phoenician princess, was abducted by Zues and they had sexual contact and had kids ( The Abduction of Europa, 2010 ) . Second, the “ colza ” of Ganymede by Zues, the narrative tells that Zeus fell in love with a Trojan prince named Ganymede. Zues abducted the male child and made him his lover. This myth was even used by Greek philosopher Plato to warrant his sexual feelings toward his male students ( Gibson, 2004 ) . Both of these myths were non treated in negative footings. These “ colzas ” went out unpunished because these sexual relationships were get downing to be a portion of the Grecian society. Last, the celebrated “ colza ” of Chrysippus by the prince of Thebes named Laios ( Atsma, 2008 ) . In the narrative, Chrysippus killed himself because of his misdemeanor ( Hubbard, 2006 ) . It was besides the first clip that one called it a offense, viz. the “ offense of Laius ” ( Carter, 2006 ) . This term is used today as one pertaining to male colza. This is the first word picture of colza as a negative thing.

In the early provinces, female parents were being trapped into a state of affairs wherein they have to remain in limited countries of their places and remain with other females. This is called gynecocracy. Besides, adult females and kids were separated from the work forces ‘s quarters. Therefore, work forces use immature male childs for sexual intercourse sooner instead than their married womans ( Xenophon, cited in deMause, no day of the month ) . Historians argue that in early provinces, matriarchate is the prevalent position. The province is governed by adult females. This is why at that clip maternal incest was widely dispersed and common ( deMause, n.d. ) . Harmonizing to historiographers, kid colza in early provinces is called “ love ” , or “ pedophelia ” translated as “ love of kids ” , or warranting it as an case of “ cheery rights ” – that kids are non bush leagues ( deMause, n.d. ) . Furthermore, the kids are being blamed for being raped. Early bookmans, particularly Grecian bookmans believe that kids are “ alone ” and necessitating sex, “ seductive, ” and as “ routinely sucking older work forces [ but ] non abused despite consuming their seniors ‘ seeds but ceremonially initiated into manhood. ” ( Rousseau, 2007 ) . Besides, It was reported that in many early provinces, male childs would be dressed as misss by their female parents and they will work every bit cocottes to be raped by priests during spiritual rites ( Spencer, 1996 ) . Work force could pick up male childs to be raped at any barbershop, in any male child whorehouse, at the issue of any of the Roman games ( McMullen, 1990 cited by deMause, n.d. ) . “ Men on a regular basis went into streets with “ scissors to do a hole in the pants of the male child and a little pillow to set in the male child ‘s oral cavity if he should shout. ” ” ( Schild, 1997 ) . Furthermore, Physicians were reportedly expected to supply lubricators for the anal incursion of male childs and besides handle the rectal cryings that consequences from being raped ( deMause, n.d. ) . Harmonizing to Plutarch, boys should believe of colza non as a pleasance, but as a responsibility ( Cantarella, 2002, cited by deMause, n.d. ) . Furthermore, in ancient Babylon and Hebrew civilizations, raped adult females are either thrown into the river or are stoned to decease in the metropoliss ( Brownmiller, cited by deMause, n.d. ) . It was besides reported that in the early Roman Empire, “ the emasculation of male childs was a large concern ” used for ravishing by the nobility and by priests ( Rousselle, 2009 cited by deMause, n.d. ) . In the clip of the Nazis, colza was used as a political tool in war – to bring forth fear anguish, and societal control in the provinces. Examples are the Serbian “ colza cantonments ” , “ comfort misss ” in Japan, usage of inmates for harlotry in Nazi concentration cantonments in WWII, mass colzas of Bengali adult females during the Pakistani/Bengali war, colzas of school misss in Kenya, buttocks colzas of adult females by armed forces in Somalia and Guatemala ( A History of Sexual Assault, 2009: p. 1 ) . These are facts that are really overpowering if one thinks of the freedom of people today. These myths, actions and beliefs are really beastly and terrifying.

In recent old ages, colza and other signifiers of sexual assault is associated with injury for a male culprit who is related to the female victim. This means that if the colza victim is married, the offense is against her hubby ; besides, if the victim is single, the offense is against her male parent. Womans were treated as belongings of work forces. They had no rights in legal and societal definitions of colza. It was merely in the 60 ‘s that the adult females started to take part and given a opportunity to voice their sentiments and beliefs – adult females ‘s motions ( A History of Sexual Assault, 2009: p. 1 ) .Today, colza is considered as a offense punishable by jurisprudence. Although there are some states are non really rigorous sing their policies and Torahs such as in India or in Africa. Rape is defined as forced, unwanted sexual assault or sexual intercourse. Furthermore, it was argued that the ground behind the reformation and redefinition of colza, sexual assault, etc. was the feminist motions. Rape is about ownership, power, and control ( A History of Sexual Assault, 2009: p. 1 ) . In the history of colza, several definitions and countenances were really hapless. Examples are: Rape was defined as forced sexual intercourse merely, penile/vagina. If the victim does non get hurts, the instance will non be prosecuted. All provinces do non admit matrimonial colza and day of the month colza as serious colza instances. Males are merely treated as suspects and can non be victims, while females are victims merely and non culprits. Merely unusual colza was acknowledged and if no physical hurts or injury were sustained, it will non be acknowledged ( A History of Sexual Assault, 2009: p. 2 ) . Merely in 2002 was there a large spring in the colza jurisprudence definitions and countenances.

There are many different grounds behind these colzas. Study of why and where is the point of making this condemnable act will beef up understanding about what colza is and why it is a offense. Harmonizing to the GMU Sexual Assault Services ( GMU-SAS ) , about 95 per centum of reported colzas are committed by work forces. However, most work forces do non perpetrate these sorts of offense ( The Offender, 2009 ) . GMU-SAS argued that there are many different factors that affect or hike the development of this aberrant behaviour. Some of these factors are: ( One ) the offender thinks of the victim as an object that can be manipulated and violated harmonizing to his will. ( Two ) The inability to sympathize to other people had resulted from physical, sexual or emotional maltreatment from the yesteryear. Harmonizing to a survey, 70 per centum of male sexual assault wrongdoers were sexually and physically abused in their childhood ( Lisak, 2002, cited in The Offender, 2009 ) . ( Three ) The culprit believes that sex is equal to force ; that work forces should be dominant and aggressive, and that adult females should protect themselves until they take that virtuousness with the usage of force. ( Four ) The culprit strongly holds on the beliefs of “ dating ritual stereotypes ” . An illustration is that sex is a “ game ” . The more you have it, whether by force or non, the more points you have. ( Five ) The culprit accepts force as an act of covering with struggles. ( Six ) Excessive imbibing of intoxicant may impact the violent attitude of some work forces ( The Offender, 2009 ) . These are merely some of the causes that may impact the development of a sexual assault culprit.

Rape has a broad assortment of instances. Rape, in the simplest classification, is divided into two Fieldss. One, non-stranger colza and two, stranger colza. These are two wholly different narratives. Non-traditional colza is defined to be rape wherein the culprit is an familiarity, a friend, a neighbour or even a partner ( Acquaintance or Non-Stranger Rape, 2009 ) . Harmonizing to the GMU Sexual Assault Services ( GMU-SAS ) , a non-stranger colza is non considered to be a “ true sexual assault ” ( 2009 ) . Most of the clip, society today tends to fault the victim for these types of colza. However, GMU-SAS argued that the no adult female is exempt from being raped. Any adult female can be raped. Besides, colza is a really “ democratic ” signifier of force. Furthermore, colza onslaughts are 80 % entirely and partly planned ( Acquaintance or Non-Stranger Rape, 2009: p. 1 ) . Besides, surveies show that 60-80 % of all sexual assaults were done by person who knows the victims. Besides, work forces can be sexually assaulted excessively. Most of the male colza victims were abused in their childhood or in their teens. Rape is non dependent on the arm used, gender, virginity and other affairs. Rape is approximately unwanted, forced actions toward a victim ( Acquaintance or Non-Stranger Rape, 2009: p. 2 ) . Marital colza is another signifier of a non-traditional colza. In 1984, matrimonial colzas were non prosecuted in Virginia. It was merely in 1986 that a reformation of the jurisprudence allows prosecution of matrimonial colzas. In recent surveies, one out of seven adult females is being sexually assaulted by their hubbies ( Marital Rape, 2009 ) .In other words, matrimonies are non an freedom when it comes to ravish. Gang colza can be another signifier of a non-traditional colza if the sexual culprits are known or have a relationship to the victim. This happens when two or more wrongdoers sexually assault a victim. GMU-SAS described pack colza as really different from the traditional familiarity colza in the sense that work forces who engage in colzas like these are the 1s who can non perpetrate an single colza. Furthermore, it was said that pack colza is a less kinky type of colza that normally associates the thing as a rite of transition or a cogent evidence of maleness ( Helen, cited by GMU-SAS, 2009 ) .These types of colza involve an familiarity or an bing relationship.

Stranger colzas are the offenses that involve entire aliens as culprits. A study from the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre ( DRCC ) show that stranger colza is increasing. “ More than half ” of all the colza victims are attacked by entire complete aliens. The DRCC is alarmed and shocked because of this turning tendency. Besides, harmonizing to their statistics, out of the 51 per centum of alien colza victims, 38 per centum said that they were besides physically and psychologically abused ( cited by Sherry, 2009 ) . Harmonizing to the Rape, Abuse, Incest National Network ( RAINN ) , alien colza has three major classs: Blitz sexual assault, Contact sexual assault, and Home invasion sexual assault. Blitz sexual assault is the type of sexual assault that happens quickly and viciously. The culprit is a entire alien and this normally happens at dark in public topographic points. Contact sexual assault involves the sudden contact of a alien culprit with the victim and attempts to derive his assurance and trust before assailing the victim. Normally, the culprits pick their victims from bars and eating houses ; sexual coercion besides is used for the induction of sexual assault. Home invasion sexual assault is the state of affairs wherein the alien culprit interruptions in the place of the victim and assail the victim ( Stranger Rape, 2009 ) . Stranger colza is reported to go on in a lesser normally and less possible to be repeated. Furthermore, it has been an statement that alien colza is associated with force and that non-stranger colzas have less force when it comes to their nature ( Shanahan, 1999 ) . This is a instead unequal judgement on the true nature of colza as an offense. Rape is colza. Rape is a offense. It does non count whether there was force or less force. It was further explained that a adult female is “ despoiled ” whenever she has sex and feels violated ( MacKinnon, cited by Shanahan, 1999 ) .

To farther explain and measure the instance of alien colza, comparing of the injuries and effects of both colzas will be discussed. There are many effects of being raped. These are really serious effects that have lifetime effects on the victim. It was reported that alien colza has far more complicated and annihilating effects for the victim. Stranger colza frequently consequences in unwanted gestations and sexually transmitted diseases which include HIV and AIDS. Furthermore, violent alien colza can do contusions and cuts to the victim, besides the absence of rubbers that make a larger chance of sexually transmitted diseases ( Best, 2005 ) . Raped adult females are traumatized and stigmatized. In some civilizations, different sorts of penalties are given to ravish adult females. Despoiled adult females are either abandoned, divorced or be declared as unmarriageable ( Best, 2005 ) . Furthermore, many raped adult females go impregnated ; contract sexually familial infections, and suffers gynaecological hurts that require rehabilitative surgery ( Best, 2005 ) . These effects are far more annihilating that one can of all time imagined. The mental, emotional, physical and psychological anguishs for these adult females are worst.

The effects and injuries of non-stranger colza are besides comparable to the effects of alien colza. It is non right to state that non-stranger colza is non violent. There is besides force in what they do. Research studies that non-stranger colza or familiarity colza subsisters suffer from depression, anxiousness, complications in subsequent relationships, and trouble of achieving maximal degree of sexual satisfaction ( Koss & A ; Dinero, cited by Curtis, 1997 ) . Besides, it is besides argued that one of the most serious effects of alien colza is Posttraumatic Stress Disorder ( PTSD ) . Furthermore, colza and other sexual assaults is the most common cause of PTSD ( McFarlane & A ; De Girolamo, in van der Kolk, McFarlane, & A ; Weisaeth cited by Curtis, 1997 ) . Other effects are abortion, spontaneous abortion, sterility, self-destructive inclinations, and long-run sexual disfunction. The effects and injuries are merely the same as with the alien colza. There should be no differentiation between alien and non-stranger colza. They are both offenses.

The penalty and jurisprudence for colza instances will be discussed to foster the apprehension of the base and position of both alien colza and non-stranger colza in stand foring the true nature of colza as an offense. The legal facets and comparings of the “ traditional ” sense for both instances is the most effectual manner in measuring the extent of which both represents the nature of colza. The legal facets of “ traditional ” colza has five major elements: incursion, force and opposition, non-consent, absence of a spousal relationship ( the matrimonial freedom ) , and a blameworthy province of head ( work forces rea ) . Merely four of the major elements are connected to stranger colza.

( 1 ) Sexual intercourse is a demand for an act to be called colza. Penetration is the, even slightest, interpolation of the phallus into the vagina. It does non number as colza if the incursion is done with the usage of object or the incursion is non done in the vagina. Furthermore, interjection is non required. This implies that traditional position of colza is gender-specific – that merely adult females can be raped. Today, modern positions about colza towards incursion is that incursion is about force and misdemeanor against the morale, physical unity and sexual liberty of a individual – adult male, adult female or kid. This means that incursion is physical incursion of any object to any portion of the organic structure of the victim ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) .

( 2 ) To be qualified as a colza instance, the culprit must hold exerted force and that the victim has no consent about it. Traditionally, other instances wherein it is considered as physical colza even without the physical irresistible impulse, are those in which the adult female was unconscious, was mentally unqualified, or gave her consent under certain false pretences. Traditionally, a culprit who tricked a victim about false pretences about matrimony and the likes are non to be considered as colza. However, he may be trialed for seduction. Besides, colza by entry must be justified by the application of force ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) . It was argued that the justification of force is non axiomatic because most people think that sex without consent, even with or without force, is to be called colza ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) . This implies that you if the victim is non forced, there is no colza. That colza is traditionally interpreted as an act of force – the more force, the more violent, the more believable the colza. Today, several provinces punish all instances of sexual intercourse without consent and dainty force simply as a factor that aggravates the badness of the discourtesy. But there are still people who believe that force is an indispensable component of colza ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) .

( 3 ) Non-consent is another issue of the traditional position of colza. A sexual assault is non considered as colza if the victim consented or did non defy. The act must be “ against his will ” . The major drawback of this component is that “ it tended to promote a focal point on the plaintiff ‘s province of head, and grounds of her anterior sexual experience was frequently used to insinuate that she wanted to hold sex ( or deserved whatever intervention she received ) ” . Furthermore, the significance of consent is non clear. Some argued that replying “ no ” does non really intend no. Such troubles arise that is why, today, some Torahs provide the riddance of the component of unwillingness or non-consent ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) .

( 4 ) Mens Rea is another traditional position of colza. It means that the suspect has a blameworthy province of head. This means that the culprit must hold existent cognition of what he has done and that he is in a proper province of head. Furthermore, strong belief should necessitate existent consciousness of wrongdoing. This implies that the “ strong belief should necessitate cogent evidence of condemnable carelessness ( a gross going from the degree of attention moderately expected ) and the punishment imposed should be lower than that applied to knowing misconduct. ” ( Rape: Legal Aspects – Forcible Rape: Elementss of the Offense, n.d. ) .

Clearly, from these traditional positions on alien colza, all of the four traditional elements: incursion, force and opposition, non-consent, and a blameworthy province of head ( work forces rea ) do non stand for reasonably and accurately the true nature of colza as an offense. It is an offense if the individual is violated physically, emotionally, mentally, and psychologically. Again, Rape is colza. Rape is a offense. It does non count who, what, where, when and how. Rape is about the devastation of one ‘s sexual liberty, of one ‘s pride and self-respect, of one ‘s wellness.


I'm Heather

Would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out