The Comparison Between Monetary Policies Finance Essay

The Monetary policy of a state is one of the most important policies, whose declaration is closely looked forward to and viewed by the universe audience. The Monetary Policy is a regulative policy thru which the cardinal bank of a state maintains its control over the supply of the money which in bend affects involvement rates for the intent of realisation of attempts towards economic development

Hire a custom writer who has experience.
It's time for you to submit amazing papers!

order now

In certain states it is the currency board or other regulative commission that determines the size and rate of growing of the money supply.

States chosen & amp ; why

For the intent of this essay I have chosen the states India, Singapore and UK. India, one time considered a slow turning economic system is the following best option for investings. However there are many factors internal every bit good as external that are impeding its growing. Many have credited India ‘s ability to minimise the effects of the 2008 fiscal crisis to The Reserve Bank of India ‘s Policy stance. Hence in current state of affairs, analyzing the pecuniary policy of the RBI makes sense.

The ground for taking Singapore is because of the rate at which it has advanced in all Fieldss including its strong fiscal system doing it today the fasting turning fiscal Centres of the universe. A comparative survey with other states can decidedly hold certain arrows.

And eventually my determination to take the Bank of England Monetary Policy is because of history. Both India and Singapore were one time British settlements and therefore pecuniary Policy comparing would help in indentifying whether history did in fact impact policies of modern twenty-four hours.

Comparison between the Policy based on assorted factors

1.Economy and their economic factors


Singapore is a extremely developed and free-market economic system with a corruption-free environment. The economic system is exports oriented, with a growing peculiarly in fiscal services sector. The preparation of pecuniary policy is based on sound economic analysis through careful surveillance of timely developments. Economic indexs frequently used are Gross domestic merchandise, A which fell an annualized 1.1 % per centum in the last one-fourth, is expected to stay modest. CPI is besides looked at with CPI-All Items rising prices easing to 4.0 % in July from 5.3 % in June 2012 and is expected to stay elevated and volatile over the coming months.Thirdly Inflation which is represented by MAS Core Inflation is lower, will remain due to the continued pass-through of earlier pay additions.


After independency, the Indian economic system was inspired by theA Soviet modelA of economic development, which was mostly public sector driven with high import responsibilities clubbed withA interventionist policies. The inefficiencies & A ; corruptness form the theoretical account led India to follow free market rules taking to liberalisation and international trade. She began to be seen as one of the swiftest-growing economic systems in the universe. But has hit many a velocity bump on its way to growing necessitating policy intercession, in peculiar pecuniary policy.

Gross Domestic Product ( GDP ) growing decelerated from 9.2 per cent in 2010-11 to 5.3 per cent in 2011-12 ( both Q4 ) . Significant failing in investing activity was the chief cause of the lag. Growth in the Index of industrial production ( IIP ) decelerated to 2.9 per cent in 2011-12. Headline Wholesale Price Index ( WPI ) rising prices was at 7.6 per cent in May before chairing to 7.3 per cent in June 2012. A The unstable planetary state of affairs, has led to India ‘s ware exports worsening by 1.7 per cent.

United kingdom:

The UK Economy used to be the largest and most powerful economic systems of the universe before the US took over. Today 3rd largest economic system in Europe and is a free market economic system. It was the fisrt to industrialize and is a dominant participant in planetary markets with its rank of EU and its position of London being a Global fiscal Centre. Thus the pecuniary policy of UK needs to look at planetary every bit good an state economic factors.

Since the Bank of rising prices undertakesA monetary value stabilityA through rising prices targeting of 2 % , rising prices is a keey factor. the market expects that pecuniary policy will respond to countervail dazes that are likely to drive rising prices off from mark. Other factor considered are GDP growing and trim capacity particularly the end product spread, Unemployment figures, Forward looking indicesA such as the Purchasing Managers ‘ Index, Trends in planetary foreign exchange markets

2.Objective of Monetary Policy

Monetary Authority of Singapore:

The pecuniary policy aim of Singapore is individual. The Monetary Authority of Singapore ‘s ( MAS ‘ ) pecuniary policy aim is monetary value stableness over the medium-term as the footing of sustainable economic growing.

The FX rates is more critical for rising prices particularly for imported rising prices as it is a much greater factor in the macro economic system than domestic rising prices. Singapore ‘s pecuniary policy has been centred on the direction of the exchange rate since the early 1980s. The pick of pecuniary policy government is predicated on the little and unfastened nature of the Singapore economic system which is extremely trade oriented.

There are three chief characteristics of the exchange rate system in Singapore.

The Singapore dollar is managed against a basket of currencies of our major trading spouses.

MAS operates a managed float government for the Singapore dollar with the trade-weighted exchange rate allowed to fluctuate within a policy set.

The exchange rate policy set is sporadically reviewed to guarantee that it remains consistent with the implicit in basicss of the economic system.

Reserve Bank of India:

The Monetary Policy in India has the undermentioned aim:

Price stableness

which means keeping the sensible rate of rising prices by commanding the liquidness and thru adjustment money demand & A ; supply.


guaranting equal handiness of recognition at a lower cost i.e. increasing the aggregative rate of nest eggs, rate of investing, apportioning investing financess for productive intents

Exchange rate stableness

supervising the exchange rate and keeping exchange rate stableness by taking suited pecuniary steps

Bank of England:

The Bank of England ‘s has two nucleus intents One is monetary value stableness and the other is to safeguard currency value. Both of which are explained below.

Monetary stableness

which means stable monetary values – low rising prices – and assurance in the currency. Stable monetary values are defined by the Government ‘s rising prices mark of 2 % , which the Bank seeks to run into through the determinations by the Monetary Policy Committee ( MPC ) . Inflation below the mark of 2 % is every bit bad as rising prices above the mark. In order to make so the MPC has to guarantee that it can supply the right conditions for sustainable growing in end product and employment. The Government ‘s rising prices mark is announced each twelvemonth by the Chancellor of the Exchequer during the one-year Budget statement.

Safeguard the value of the currency

Safeguard the value of the currency in footings of what it will buy. Higher monetary values -reduces the value of money, therefore pecuniary policy is directed at making model for non-inflationary economic growing. Inflation if high, can be damaging to the operation of the economic system whereas lower rising prices helps to further sustainable long-run economic growing.


Monetary Authority of Singapore:

a.Foreign Exchange rate Policy

The MAS has three attacks to alter its exchange rate policy base.

The first being altering the incline of the trade weighted basket.

The 2nd option is to alter the centre point of the set up/down to tighten/loosen pecuniary policy.

The 3rd option is to narrow/widen the set of the NEER ( Nominal Effective Exchange rate ) . The MAS may on some occasions widen the breadth of the set temporarily to suit heightened fiscal or economic volatility.

b.MAS Standing Facility

MAS operates a cardinal liquidness installation for Real Time Gross Settlement ( RTGS ) -participating Bankss. It is price reduction window, available to let take parting Bankss to set about Singapore dollar sedimentations or barter for Singapore dollar by utilizing eligible foreign currencies. These Bankss may besides borrow Singapore dollars via repo of eligible collateral from MAS on interest-paying and nightlong footing. The involvement rate is for the installation is the mention rate +/- 50 footing points. The mention rate is is based on the leaden norm of successful commands for MAS ‘ S $ 500m nightlong loan or clean adoption conducted during Money Market Operations, the same twenty-four hours.

The take parting Bankss have to come in into the PSA-ISMA Global Master Repurchase Agreement with MAS. Besides the single borrowing/deposit may either increase/decrease the sum of banking system liquidity.A

MAS Intraday Liquidity Facility

The MAS intraday liquidness installation is provided to RTGS participants that may necessitate to do remarkably big payments or anticipate big grosss within the same twenty-four hours. Participants may obtain financess through intraday repo minutess from MAS which can include Singapore Government Securities ( SGS ) and MAS Bills. Liquidity Thus it enables colony of payments amongst Bankss and Bankss ‘ refunds to MAS without holding to supply extra liquidness. The liquidness reversal takes topographic point on the same twenty-four hours.

c.MAS Bills

Therefore till July 2010, MAS used three instruments i ) FX barters or contrary barters ; ( two ) SGS repos or change by reversal repos ; and ( three ) clean loaning or adoption to shoot and retreat liquidness into and from the banking system at its day-to-day MMO. A forth instrument was created with the debut of MAS Bills.

The altering regulative landscape has seen a greater demand for authorities and cardinal bank debt securities amid the banking system and higher liquidness demands. Therefore, the installation meets the demands of Singaporean Bankss for liquid assets.

MAS Bills are issued on a regular basis and with a adulthood runing from 4, 6, 8 hebdomads, up to 3 months. The issue calendar is pre-announced in May and November for the undermentioned half-year.The timing and sum of single MAS Bill issues is decided by MAS, in audience with primary traders.

Reserve Bank of India


Banks have to keep a per centum of their net demand and clip liabilities ( NDTL ) in the signifier of hard currency militias with the cardinal bank partially as a statutory demand and partially for prudential grounds. The balance/ extra sedimentations can be lent. The RBI is empowered to find CRR in the scope of 3 to 15 % of aggregative demand & A ; clip liabilities. The pecuniary Policy of the RBI will denote RBI ‘s move either to maintain CRR unchanged or to cut down or increase the CRR per centum depending on the prevalent economic environment, therefore doing it a tool for liquidness direction.

The two intents it serves are ( a ) A ensures that a per centum of bank sedimentations is unbroken riskless, ( B ) enables RBI toA control banking system liquidness


Banks have to keep the per centum of their net demand and clip liabilities ( NDTL ) in the signifier of A bullion, gold or govt. approved securities with the cardinal bank partially as a statutory demand and partially for prudential reasons.Currently the SLR was reduced to 23 % of NDTL from 24 % harmonizing to the pecuniary Policy Review.

Open Market Operations ( OMOs )

RBI besides conducts OMOs which are market operations affecting purchase/sale of Govt. securities from/to the market with an aim of seting the rupee liquidness conditions. When the RBI feels there is extra liquidness it resorts to sale of thereby squashing out the rupee liquidness. Similarly, when the liquidness conditions are tight, the RBI will purchase securities from the market, therefore shooting liquidness.

OMO affect banking in two ways

1 ) set uping the militias

2 ) through signaling of involvement rates based on lower limit & A ; maximal involvement rates set for purchase & A ; sale of govt securities.

Repo and Reverse Repo

Repo and Reverse repo are money market operations thru which the RBI injects or suctions out liquidness signifier the banking system. The two rates used are the Repo rate and change by reversal repo rate. The RBI lends to commercial Bankss by and large against collateral of authorities securities at the repo rate. Reverse Repo rate is the rate at which RBI borrows money from them. The current Repo Rate is 8 % and Reverse Repo Rate is 7 %

c.Bank Rate Policy

RBI lends commercial Bankss through its price reduction window. The involvement rate which it charges to commercial Bankss for this intent is bank rate.

d.Marginal Standing Facility

There are certain eligible entities can avail overnight, up to 1 % of their several Net Demand and Time Liabilities ( NDTL ) outstanding at the terminal of the 2nd preceding two weeks. However, if a Bankss ‘ SLR retentions autumn below the statutory demand upto 1 % of their NDTL, so it will non hold the duty to seek a specific release as a consequence of default originating out of usage of this installation.

e.Standing Liquidity Facility

Is a liquidness direction installation provided to Bankss ( export recognition refinance ) and Primary Traders ( PDs ) ( collateralised liquidness support ) by the Reserve Bank at the repo rate, A of 8 % with consequence from April 17, 2012.

Bank of England:

a.Reserve demands

Reserve demands are a agencies to change the short term demand for reserve money and therefore impacting short term involvement rates. Banks can adjest tjeir balance sheet in response to the altering modesty demands and the consequence on long term involvement rates depends on the extent of fiscal intermediation.

b.Open market operations

OMOs are conducted by the Bank of England as per Ti taking so as to supply financess back to the market by imparting against collateral. This is done via Repo or Reverse Repo.OMOs are divided into regular and irregular depending on their happening. the cardinal bank may keep a OMO where it aould announce in progress of an auction where participants are invited to take part. presently in UK a group of money market counterparties are invited twice a twenty-four hours to offer for refinance of financess. they offer authorities securities of EEA govt. debt for short term repo.Irregular operation are conducted via measures sold or bought in response to planetary and domestic short term economic developments.

c.Standing installations

The Bank of England besides provides Standing Facilities ( SFs ) besides referred to as adoption or sedimentation installations made available to Bankss and fiscal establishments as per their choosing. The recognition installation acts as an option for adoption and the sedimentation installation is for puting extra financess.

Standing recognition installations are known as Lombard installations which are short term liquidness to Bankss on demand and nightlong. Deposit installations are used to set a floor to market rates at a given adulthood. in a market broad excess liquidness state of affairs sedimentation standing installation becomes an effectual policy instrument.

d.Quantitative Easing

The term Quantitative Easing ( QE ) is a signifier of pecuniary policy that cardinal Bankss use so as to increase theA supply of moneyA in an economic system. This is done when theA bank involvement rate, A price reduction rateA and/orA interbank involvement rateA are at near zero degree. It is done via plus purchases. The policy is designed to besiege the banking system wherein the Bank of England creates new money electronically so as to buy gildings from fiscal establishments. These investors use it to buy assets, like corporate bonds and portions. This in bend reduces longer-term costs of borrowing and encourages primary equity and bond issues.

The Monetary Policy Committee ( MPC ) in 2009 made an proclamation sing the decrease of the Bank Rate to 0.5 % . As there was no leeway for farther decrease, to give a farther pecuniary stimulation to the economic system, it took the determination to set about plus purchases.

4.Role of Monetary Policy during the Crisis

Monetary Authority of Singapore

Since April 2004, MAS had maintained the policy of modest and gradual grasp of the Singapore dollar against a trade weighted basket of currencies ( referred to as the NEER ) . In add-on, in October 2007, MAS raised the incline of the NEER set to let their currency to appreciate faster, in order to undertake rising prices. When MAS pecuniary policy next took topographic point in April 2008, there were warning marks of the impending planetary recession and fiscal turbulency. Although, MAS did admit the hazards of planetary lag, they chose to concentrate on house domestic growing mentality and high rising prices. Given rising prices concerns, MAS decided to fasten pecuniary policy by switching the NEER set higher, by raising the center of the set higher.

By October 2008, the fiscal crisis had hit the planetary economic system. Singapore ‘s GDP growing feel aggressively and rising prices slowed as trade good monetary values declined. In response, MAS decided to switch to a impersonal pecuniary policy stance, i.e. they moved to zero grasp of the NEER set. After keeping, a modest grasp policy for 4 old ages, Singapore decided to allow the currency remain level which was expected to assist advance exports and push GDP growing higher.

In the period of late 2008 and early 2009, the SGD weakened within the NEER set as planetary fiscal hazard antipathy continued. Singapore ‘s GDP contracted badly post the crisis and MAS decided to ease pecuniary policy further. MAS lowered the mid-point of the NEER set lower, therefore farther weakening the currency against its trading spouses. By late 2009 and early 2010, Singapore ‘s economic system recovered and MAS raised the incline back to positive, therefore returning back to their old stance of modest currency grasp. Presently, the incline of the NEER set continues to be positive.

Reserve Bank of India

Prior to the 2008 crisis i.e between 2003 & A ; 2008, the Indian economic system was turning at a fast gait thanks to the rule-based financial policy which supported pecuniary policy in efficaciously concentrating on rising prices control and enlargement of recognition in a non-inflationary mode. Inflation was low and stable. Fiscal stableness with equal money supply growing was made available so as to keep the resource balance consistent with the demands of a fast turning economic system.

While the Earth was confronting the 2008 crisis, the Indian economic system was safeguarded thanks to attempts of the RBI. These included both conventional and unconventional methods. From October 2008 and April 2009 the undermentioned stairss were taken

the repo rate was reduced by 425 footing points to 4.75 per cent

the rearward repo rate was reduced by 275 footing points to 3.25 per cent

CRR was reduced by a cumulative 400 footing points to 5.0 per cent

The actual/potential proviso of primary liquidness was Rs. 5.6 trillion

Table 5: Monetary and Inflation Indexs

( Per cent )



( 2003-08 )


( 2008-12 )

2012-13 ( Latest )







1. Sweeping Price Index




1.1 Food Articles




1.2 Fuel Group




1.3 Non-Food Mfg.




2. CPI- Industrial Workers ( IW )




2.1 CPI- IW Food




GDP Deflator based Inflation



We are presently in 2008-12 stage of station crisis where growing has moderated but rising prices is lifting and perplexing the undertaking of pecuniary direction. The stairss taken in this respect were go outing from the crisis-driven pecuniary policy stance by phasing out all the unconventional steps thenceforth raising involvement rates. Growth moderated but it was coupled with marks of lifting WPI rising prices due to high nutrient monetary values particularly protein based points. This led to the Reserve Bank cutting the repo rate by 50 footing points to 8.0 per cent in April 2012.

Therefore by synchronizing the liquidness direction operations, exchange rate and internal debt direction operations, RBI ensured that liquidness was maintained within the system, consistent with the aim of pecuniary policyA

Bank of England

Get downing 2007, the Bank of England intervened so as to make a proviso for equal sterling liquidness with scope of operations. The Particular Liquidity Scheme for Bankss was launched In April 2008, imparting for three old ages.

Thereafter, the Discount Window Facility was opened so as to supply liquidness insurance to the banking system. Loans normally take the signifier of a collateral barter in which the Bank lends UK authorities debt ( gildings ) against eligible collateral. A dealing of this signifier does non impact the Banks militias.

The Bank of England has besides introduced since long-run repo operations each month, loaning at three, six, nine and twelve-month adulthoods. In September 2008, the Bank increased the frequence and the sum of its three-month loaning every bit good as expanded the scope of eligible collateral to include asset-backed securities and covered bonds.

Thereafter in March 2009 the rate decrease to 0.5 % seemed unequal as a pecuniary stimulation. In order to work out the issue the Bank of England introduced Quantitative Easing between March and November 2009. QE began with the purchase of ?200 billion worth of UK Government debt, followed by a farther purchase of ?75 billion in October 2011

In December 2011, the Bank announced the add-on of a new installation under which it could auction liquidness against a broad set of collateral eligible in the Discount Window.A

In February 2012 the the MPC ( Monetary Policy Committee ) bought an extra ?50 bn.A A In July 2012 entire assets purchases were brought to ?375 bn with a farther purchase ?50bn

Decision and Challenges Ahead

Therefore we find that each of the states and their Cardinal Bankss each have aims based on the macroeconomic basicss of their economic systems.

However they besides portion similar instruments like standing installations and really alone 1s like quantitative easing undertaken by the Bank of England as steps during the crisis.

Some cardinal differences observed between the pecuniary policy of RBI and those of advanced economic systems is that liquidness injection the counter-parties involved were through banking channels and the RBI balance sheet did non demo unusual addition.

Today with the Euro crisis looming overhead India, Singapore and UK and RBI face the challenge of go outing from the current pecuniary policy adjustment and seting their balance sheets depending on the place of the economic system in the concern rhythm.

Cardinal Banks of advanced economic systems where balance sheets have expanded well into non aureate securities like mortgage-backed securities and corporate bond, face the challenge of making issue schemes depending upon the velocity of recovery in single market sections.

Therefore what is normally seen as a challenge to the three cardinal bank is the focal point has shifted from pull offing the crisis to pull offing the recovery.


I'm Heather

Would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out