“A Rose for Emily” . by William Faulkner and “The Lottery” . by Shirley Jackson are both short narratives that deal with struggle from either the community or separately. Faulkner hints us readers the chief struggle in “A Rose for Emily” is non merely Emily but other characters in this short narrative. For “The Lottery” . Jackson hints the readers the struggle is more on the societal side intending the community or society non merely the chief characters. But the chief comparings between these two short narratives are the characters. and the communities that seem to be stuck in the yesteryear.
William Faulkner starts the short narrative off with stating the character Emily. from “A Rose for Emily” . is dead. Faulkner divides the short narrative into five parts. and those five parts talk about Emily’s life which is spoken from the town’s position. Emily is described as a load. whose “old fashioned” and is fundamentally a average old lady. The first portion starts off with Emily non desiring to pay her revenue enhancements and the city manager sets up a meeting of the Board of Aldermen to her place. Not merely was she demoing no manners. she kept stating she had no revenue enhancements to pay and state her retainer. “the Negro” to demo the gentlemen out. The short narrative continues on with adverting Emily’s father’s decease. The town’s people felt regretful for Emily. non merely on the fact that he passed off but the fact that her male parent was a controlling adult male. Controling intending her male parent didn’t want her to seek work forces. Emily was in denial for her father’s decease. “She told them her male parent was non dead. She did that for three days” ( 151 ) . She couldn’t allow her father go because her male parent was her life and that was the lone life she had.
The other parts talk about Emily’s sweetie named Homer Baron. Everyone in town are happy about her holding a sweetie. but it goes downhill one time they find out Homer Baron liked immature work forces. Emily ends up purchasing toxicant and it wasn’t easy purchasing since the pharmacist was funny as to why Emily wanted it for. The townsfolk on the other manus assumed it was so she can kill herself since she’s traveling through a batch. But Emily doesn’t merely purchase rat toxicant ; she ends up purchasing hologram lavatory set with H. B written on them. Six months has passed by and Emily hasn’t been seen. till one twenty-four hours when people noticed her weight addition. Towards the terminal of the narrative the people noticed the Negro ( retainer ) runs off while Emily is deceasing. They so open a door and the first thing the town’s people notice is Homer Baron’s organic structure being decayed. Following to his organic structure was a print of a organic structure that seemed to put at that place every dark and a piece of Emily’s grey hair.
“The Lottery” . by Shirley Jackson is about a little town that gathered in a square on a summer twenty-four hours. June 27th. When you think of “Lottery” you likely assume something positive that trades with money. But that’s non true. in this short narrative “The Lottery” is a ritual that’s been traveling on for coevalss. It has to make with throwing a stone to a individual that gets a grade in the center of the paper. all towns had stopped making this ritual but this was the lone town that continued. The individual who’s in charge of this rite is Mr. Summers along with a assistant Mr. Graves who’s the station maestro. The Lottery starts off with blending the documents inside a box and naming out the names from a list. Once everyone had picked out the paper and seen if they had got picked. the people in the small town noticed Bill Hutchison ended up acquiring the black point. Tessie who is the married woman. stands up for her hubby and say’s it wasn’t a just choice so Mr. Summer gives them another opportunity. Everyone in the household got to pick a paper out and this clip Tessie ends up acquiring picked. Now since it’s a ritual it was something you had to make. that’s when everyone in the small town including Tessie’s household picked up stones and threw it to her. “It isn’t carnival. it isn’t right. ” ( 192 ) Tessie invariably is shouting this because she knew this wasn’t right. it wasn’t right to kill an inexperienced person over a ritual.
Both these short narratives seem to fall in a similar comparing which is struggle between single and the community. The storyteller in “A Rose for Emily” gives away that Emily is stubborn ; she doesn’t attention at what anyone says of her. But in this short narrative it’s non merely one struggle. its several struggles we notice. One was Emily’s male parent ; she didn’t want to allow his organic structure travel because he was her merely life particularly since he was controlled. Another struggle was the community and Emily. Peoples that lived in that town would ever state rumours. and fundamentally won’t help her they would merely sit back and delay. Then we have Emily and Homer Baron. Emily was lonely. and Homer seemed to be the lone individual that was person she loved. Even if it didn’t turn out the manner she hoped. she knew merely holding his presence there was plenty.
So this shows Emily had struggles with world. present and past. and being lonely. “The Lottery” . on the other manus was struggle between community and individualism. for illustration Tessie and the small town she was populating in. The whole ritual “The Lottery” symbolizes any wickedness or any bad behaviour that has been caused to be passed down from coevals to coevals no affair how cruel it could be. Tessie is against this whole rite. she finds it non fair because of killing an guiltless individual. Old Man Warner was besides another individual who noticed this ritual wasn’t right. he notices the alterations throughout all the old ages he’s been about. He mentions. “It’s non the manner it used to be. ” “People ain’t the manner they used to be. ” ( 191 ) . In “The Lottery” it shows that no affair if the box alterations. the ritual will ever stay the same. and alternatively of the town really halting this from go oning they join. The past and the community seem to be one of the other noticeable struggles. The ground for why Tessie could’ve besides been shouting out “It isn’t fair” because this ritual has ended everyplace else but continued in this small town. The small town is still keeping onto the ritual that’s been taking clasp for so long that they aren’t truly believing of any other effects. Both of these short narratives fall into somewhat of the same struggle. Like Emily. if she wasn’t so focussed into the past significance being “old fashioned” so she would’ve fit good into the society without experiencing lonely. As for Tessie and her small town. if they stopped go oning a ritual that was held on for so long so Tessie wouldn’t have been killed.